what is citalopram medication for cheap citalopram uk dexamethasone decadron medication buy decadron uk cost comparison roxithromycin mg buy roxithromycin lowest price clozaril prescription clozaril buy uk brand ditropan for sale order ditropan pharmacy prescription brand trandate for sale trandate from canada hyzaar canadian pharmacy hyzaar cost comparison buy female viagra australia can viagra be bought over the counter in canada diclofenac combination paracetamol diclofenac gel.com cheap crestor 20mg online canada order crestor calan commercial calan in usa bringing viagra from mexico buy viagra cheap online no prescription tetracycline generic price buy generic tetracycline bacterial compazine without prescriptions compazine medication levitra online paypal buy brand levitra lowest price allopurinol discount anti acidity certain types allopurinol usa medicine cipro hc Purchase cipro 250 mg singulair generic equivalent cheap singulair no prescription paroxetine prescription cr paroxetine prescription information tablets abilify without pharmacy buy abilify online no prescription femara without ovidrel femara user reviews price of zyvox 400 mg generic zyvox 1200 mg weight gain from seroquel 25mg ordering seroquel online seroquel generic available in us cost of seroquel without insurance ordering pyridium online canada order pyridium canadian pharmacy cialis professional generic cialis online pharmacy review levitra for sale online generic levitra professional review bupropion 75 mg reviews bupropion generic brands over the counter weight loss alli diet pill buy alli 120mg purchase clonidine online clonidine medication adhd medication buy tamoxifen citrate uk tamoxifen generic available overnight pharmacy cialis super active cialis super active reviews depakote medication bipolar depakote no prescription periactin canada no prescription periactin online bestellen levitra india availability levitra medication assistance generic cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews generic cialis online reviews actos pharmacy discount buy actos with type diabetes lipitor no prescription lipitor generic equivalent canada anti nausea medication compazine compazine generic drug femara complaints femara online meds how much is generic effexor xr teva cheap effexor xr 150mg cefixime buy uk pharmacies cefixime prescription mg buy cialis professional discount cialis pharmacy online low albendazole albendazole drugs com buy cabgolin generic buy cabgolin mg when will generic lexapro be available in the us buy lexapro no prescription buy ventolin online cheap buy ventolin online australia antivert medication meclizine antivert buy uk generic viagra pharmacy reviews order viagra professional cheap premarin prescription assistance premarin india india metoclopramide tablets during pregnancy metoclopramide prescription information buy celebrex usa ordering celebrex online cheapest drug paroxetine where to paroxetine drug ocd buy propranolol online uk propranolol without prescriptions order celexa 40 mg celexa pharmacy online viagra canadian pharmacy online viagra soft online pharmacy indian aciphex rabeprazole sodium buy generic aciphex tablets buy alesse online canada prescription alesse online legal to buy viagra online order viagra 50 mg cardizem and heparin compatibility cardizem generic form synthroid in india synthroid drugstore com buy brand viagra no prescription viagra in boots uk cephalexin 500mg for dogs dosage cephalexin in canada order cialis with prescription buy cialis online in canada discount sell amantadine canadian mexico buy amantadine cheap us pharmacy allopurinol overnight allopurinol without prescription premarin without rx generic premarin canada legal to buy retin-a 0,05 retin-a 0,05 over counter without a script buy depakote cod depakote pharmacy cialis super active order online how to order cialis online in canada vermox generic Purchase vermox 100mg buy plendil discount delivery plendil without generic proscar australia buy proscar australia evista competition evista generic form where to purchase accutane Purchase accutane 20mg online depakote comments depakote online pharmacy hyzaar paypal indian hyzaar aldactone prescription drug ordering aldactone pharmacy us buy depakote online generic depakote reviews bipolar ii finpecia in canada finpecia drugs order tenormin 50 mg tenormin mexico minocycline pharmacy online prescription drug minocycline used legal to buy ephedraxin buy ephedraxin mg purchase revatio lowest price revatio medication coupons prilosec pharmacies prilosec overnight no prescription buy advair diskus online cheap advair diskus generic inhaler buy compazine compazine online meds order tenormin online tenormin generic purchase stromectol online stromectol discount code cialis professional online uk current price cialis professional cheapest buy generic accutane online order accutane no rx isotretinoin buy alli 120 count online orlistat 60mg capsules no prescription fast alli atarax no prescription needed atarax common dosage trazodone drugstore trazodone prescription medicine 1 Purchase abilify online pharmacy without pharmacy cheap abilify effexor xr generic brand effexor xr generic cost equivalent clonidine medications generic clonidine in use catapres prevacid reviews i prevacid from canada levothroid no prescription levothroid.com vermox dosage children buy vermox plus prevacid interactions other drugs legal to buy prevacid levitra super active shortage levitra generico quanto costa over the counter amantadine online amantadine pharmacy online methotrexate pills methotrexate without alkalinization overnight pharmacy ortho tri-cyclen ortho tri-cyclen canadian pharmacy where does tamoxifen come from buy tamoxifen online uk is accutane over the counter prescription buy accutane 40 mg online prescription generic name for minocycline order minocycline online is there a generic for celebrex celebrex medication dosage order flagyl cheap generic flagyl metronidazole antifungal drug purchase brand levitra lowest price levitra professional overseas periactin pills used where can i buy periactin cyproheptadine trazodone from anti herpes trazodone over the counter buy lasix cheap lasix from alli pharmacy2u where buy alli diet pill buy actos mexico when will generic actos be available generic abilify in canada buy generic abilify online 10mg lotensin hct generic lotensin pharmacy online valtrex for sale valtrex delivery buy valtrex over the counter valtrex prescription coupon generic actos when buy actos cheap online canadian pharmacy xenical diet pills reviews xenical pills canada non prescription viagra canada order viagra online motilium without rx motilium online order pyridium in canada availability pyridium over the counter dosage lamisil pills medication lamisil over the counter tablets isoniazid from generic name for isoniazid cheapest lamisil lamisil once reviews best online viagra pharmacy prescription viagra cialis generic antivert over the counter cheapest antivert online pharmacy cialis overnight no prescription purchase female cialis online lasix online pharmacy no prescription lasix trade name and generic name quickest levitra professional levitra from canadian pharmacies trazodone overnight withdrawal symptoms from trazodone antidepressant what is prednisone medication where can i buy prednisone online cheap terramycin cats terramycin from canada buspar canadian source buspar medication buspirone generic viagra australia reviews purchase viagra from canada augmentin overnight pharmacy buy augmentin online uk fluoxetine reviews of fluoxetine generic name buy clomid online ireland buy clomid uk no prescription hydrochlorothiazide from canada generic name for hydrochlorothiazide lisinopril celexa over counter order celexa united states diflucan dosage for yeast infection in men buy diflucan online no prescription liposafe from canada liposafe pills brand plavix for sale drugs similar to plavix buy bactrim online no prescription bactrim ds online no prescription save prevacid pharmacy coupon shortage of prevacid solutabs medication assistance for plavix plavix pills side effects stromectol cost comparison cod canadian stromectol canadian source how much does a prescription of zithromax cost zithromax from pfizer buy synthroid online cheap synthroid reviews viagra jelly pharmacy online cheap viagra pills for sale prozac fluoxetine reviews buy fluoxetine online no prescription uk aciphex over the counter gastroesophageal reflux canadian aciphex antiulcer rabeprazole vermox prescription drug vermox discount pharmacy prescription nexium prescription cost 20mg nexium discounted bactroban buy uk bactroban cream no prescription cheap non prescription tretinoin 0,05 tretinoin 0,05 canadian pharmacy aldactone comments aldactone for sale prescription mobic 14 where mobic drugs order erection packs 1 cialis buy cialis 20 mg buy cheap aciphex online aciphex without a script canada order female cialis how much is cialis in canada zetia from merck buy zetia china generic celebrex from canada celebrex reviews 2010 where to buy alli from drugs buy alli weight loss uk achieve prednisolone tablets for cats prednisolone cost comparison enhancement prescription skelaxin prescription information skelaxin pills uses without script overnight allopurinol online medication for gout allopurinol where to buy glucophage diabetes medicine glucophage methotrexate without folate methotrexate online no prescription how to get off effexor xr effexor xr prescription cheap acticin 2 pharmacy buy acticin celebrex com manufactur coupon when will generic celebrex be available can you get high from levaquin quickest levaquin order amitriptyline online buy generic elavil Purchase amitriptyline 50 mg lexapro overnight delivery lexapro 20 mg tablet levitra pills women levitra professional uk boots generic accutane reviews cheap accutane 5mg prescription indian vytorin vytorin online meds buy bupron sr no prescription bupron sr no prescription cialis super active discount code legal to buy female cialis buy iv zyvox cost zyvox 600 mg iv aciphex user reviews cheap aciphex us order canada doxycycline hyclate online doxycycline prescription cost cheap augmentin 875-125 mg augmentin india price Purchase crestor 40 mg order crestor 10 mg synthroid generic side effects generic synthroid overnight erection packs 3 cialis buy female cialis discount finpecia prescriptions finpecia from inhouse bystolic on line bystolic medication used clomid medication side effects buy cheap clomid online uk purchase clonidine no prescription clonidine tablets bp hydrochlorothiazide brands india buy hydrochlorothiazide triamterene quickest levitra super active buy levitra professional visa generic viagra online canadian pharmacy online viagra viagra super active without prescription where cozaar high blood pressure cozaar without overnight delivery order aldactone aldactone compound mebendazole albendazole over the counter cats no prescription needed buy albendazole online fluoxetine generic price fluoxetine reviews uk buy generic paxil online withdrawal from paxil cr cephalexin online prescription cephalexin drugs amaryl price india pharmacy amaryl on line zyvox 600 mg price discount pfizer antibiotic zyvox complicated canadian acticin online discount prescription drug acticin what date is lexapro going generic generic lexapro in 2012 pyridium generico pyridium delivery can i buy viagra over the counter in canada viagra online pharmacy us viagra soft pharmacy online over the counter drugs that work like viagra buy elimite cheap elimite cream for scabies over the counter buy lexapro online pharmacy switching from effexor xr to lexapro online viagra pharmacy reviews generic brand viagra purchase propecia pill propecia online pharmacy australia levitra professional pharmacy levitra generic name hyzaar discount card hyzaar medication coupons medrol order online medrol generic prices elavil pills buy elavil paypal order nexium 20mg tablet current price nexium tetracycline dosage rosacea tetracycline lowest shipping buy overnight pharmacy betnovate low cost betnovate buy prednisone online now prednisone generic price getting viagra from boots buy viagra online overnight delivery pyridium overnight delivery pyridium medication prescription quickest bupropion hydrochloride bupropion hcl reviews order plavix tablets plavix dosage adults amoxil no prescription buy current price amoxil pyridium non prescription pyridium over the counter australia where to buy propecia online forums generic propecia canada do you have to be 16 to buy alli pills buy alli 120 mg orlistat cafergot from canadian pharmacy cafergot delivery order lexapro 10mg no prescription how long to get lexapro out of your system prescription mobic 15 anti mobic tablets 15mg used levothroid compound levothroid prescription ranitidine over the counter uk ranitidine dosage by weight trandate in usa trandate no prescription buy robaxin no prescription what kind of medicine is robaxin buy cheap augmentin online amoxil purchase augmentin cheap reviews on xenical orlistat over the counter orlistat xenical cost of paxil generic where to buy paxil legal to buy brand cialis cialis soft buy uk buy alesse 21 drug generic alesse online discount cymbalta online pharmacy buy cymbalta online cheap stromectol cost comparison canadian pharmacy stromectol discount buy levlen online pharmacy tri levlen reviews alli on prescription is there a generic for alli buy celexa online pharmacy how to get celexa out of your system order levaquin online no prescription overnight levaquin nexium medicine alternative nexium canada generic where to buy accutane with no prescription without buy accutane online buy seroquel online uk what is the generic name for seroquel ordering xenical canada prescription xenical diet pills buy alli ireland prescription online no prescription fast alli tinidazole online prescription metronidazole or tinidazole over the counter when will generic avapro be available avapro tablets available australia levaquin generic equivalent generic for levaquin 500mg how to get plavix free plavix like drugs indian viagra jelly online drug buy viagra no prescription canada alli discount prices prescription needed buy alli online canadian buy cheap lipitor no prescription lipitor online no prescription cheap paxil paroxetine reviews paroxetine order online buy clomid 200mg licensed pharmacy clomid non prescription betnovate betnovate prescription advair diskus in canada asthma medication fluticasone advair diskus kamagra generic viagra sildenafil citrate where can i order viagra without a transcript allopurinol pills allopurinol without prescriptions norvasc medication assistance program norvasc pills paxil order online paxil from walmart what is the generic name for crestor crestor com cost order amitriptyline without elavil amitriptyline common dosage buy orlistat 120mg online order orlistat 120mg canada where lisinopril generic for lisinopril 10 mg lisinopril tablets 10 mg buy lisinopril mg erythromycin fish medicine erythromycin buy online uk elavil no prescription elavil reviews alternative drugs to metformin linagliptin metformin combination femara from canada generic femara letrozole 2.5 mg ordering levitra professional order levitra plus online zoloft without a rx is zoloft generic tinidazole generic name buy tinidazole online uk buy orlistat 120mg online orlistat generico buy us pharmacy antivert online can you buy antivert over the counter vertigo buy brand amoxil online amoxil overnight 500mg prescription how to get off paxil cold turkey paxil online buy order tamoxifen 10 mg tamoxifen online order viagra mexico pharmacy viagra medicine use mexican nolvadex nolvadex online meds Purchase adalat one pharmacy through lok adalat settlement how to store nitroglycerin tablets nitroglycerin no prescription nexium class action lawsuits buy nexium no prescription online pharmacy buspar generic brand buspar low blood pressure what color is lisinopril pills lisinopril canada generic viagra fast delivery viagra jelly overnight order buy elimite pharmacy buy elimite cream from canada levothroid without rx levothroid composition how much does generic zoloft cost zoloft prescription assistance buy alli lowest price buy 120 uk alli diet crestor complications order crestor rosuvastatin calcium alli canadian pharmacy alli weight loss buy online prescriptions buy order alesse buy alesse 21 online discount indocin drugstore indocin.com levaquin compatible with potassium chloride generic for levaquin united states generic cialis in india buy generic cialis india how to get tinidazole tinidazole in canada buy robaxin online cheap robaxin user reviews proscar online pharmacy proscar medication where clomid cialis female cialis low cost erythromycin from india erythromycin medication cost is there generic viagra in canada buy viagra no prescription needed where to ampicillin ampicillin no prescription uk xenical from mexico xenical generic lexapro medication guide is lexapro going generic in 2012 minocycline generic buy online minocycline over the counter where vpxl visa pharmacies buy vpxl cheap generic order medrol from medrol medication used risperdal medicine used risperdal online pharmacy levitra online pharmacy levitra super active online pharmacy order strattera online no prescription strattera low cost buy cheap valtrex australia where can you buy valtrex over the counter propranolol no prescription propranolol discounted info on trazodone medication sleep medication trazodone exelon buy uk exelon patch generic name common side effects of cardizem purchase cardizem online generic hyzaar available hyzaar generic lotensin no prescription buy lotensin no prescription avalide pharmacy online avalide medication price ordering furosemide online buy furosemide with no prescription transcript purchase albendazole without ordering overnight delivery albendazole online generic viagra no prescription needed generic viagra from india propecia medication for hair loss is propecia available in canada buy trazodone no prescription c.o.d prescription sleep aids trazodone generic drug for advair diskus advair diskus generic form order elavil cheap buy elavil online canada cheap diovan 80mg diovan hct generic available mobic prescriptions prescription 15 buy mobic generic cialis soft viagra female viagra tablets india overnight top offers pariet online pariet from canada increasing dosage of celexa order celexa online no prescription zyprexa medication olanzapine zyprexa medication uses amantadine usa amantadine generic symmetrel singulair dosage for kids singulair medicine for asthma cheapest drug arimidex arimidex for sale buy allopurinol online no prescription allopurinol over the counter blog how to get off prilosec naturally prilosec mexico brand otc albendazole delivery prescription albendazole medication buy stromectol pills cost comparison buy stromectol pharmacy uk buy accutane online cheap accutane pharmacies online protonix prescription canada protonix no prescription lipitor prescription medicine lipitor online pharmacy ampicillin free shipping buy ampicillin with no prescription buy trial erection packs 2 visa non prescription trial erection packs 2 female viagra from pfizer viagra jelly shortage buy evista uk evista overnight pharmacy current price adalat adalat overseas can you buy clomid online provera pills clomid alli pills side effects buy alli online amazon purchase terramycin online cheap terramycin cost comparison pharmacy generic suhagra suhagra canadian pharmacy buy flagyl 500mg online no prescription dosage of flagyl for dogs order elavil antidepressant weight gain from elavil is there a generic cymbalta what is in cymbalta medication prednisolone medication information prednisolone generic methotrexate tablets can you buy methotrexate over counter antabuse without prescription antabuse dosage weight nitroglycerin drugs nitroglycerin medication class generic levaquin release date levaquin reviews prescription cost allopurinol online generic for allopurinol prescription 100mg no prescription generic advair diskus online advair diskus in canada how to get methotrexate methotrexate manufacturers in usa buy medrol online no rx medrol canada generic cialis softtabs mail order brand cialis from canada best over the counter viagra generic viagra pharmacy where to buy tetracycline online overnight reviews on tetracycline metformin medicine uk buy metformin cheap lisinopril pills side effects lisinopril generic for zestril Purchase adalat 4 pharmacy generic adalat india overnight methotrexate mouth sores from methotrexate side effects of cholesterol medication crestor order crestor 10mg ranitidine discounted ranitidine over the counter purchase propecia online no prescription order propecia online no prescription alesse discount code alesse pills cost what is clomid medication increasing clomid dosage buy generic accutane guaranteed quality indian accutane online generic generic diflucan effective canada buy diflucan online prescription lamisil pharmacy nail lamisil generic name canada order propranolol propranolol cost comparison prescription buy cheap Purchase abilify 20 mg abilify discounts free buy paxil online pharmacists paxil pharmacy online diovan hct medication blood diovan medication pressure generic form of alesse order alesse online without avapro tablets 150mg over the counter generic avapro propranolol sleeping pills propranolol hydrochloride 10mg tablets fluoxetine india fluoxetine patient reviews generic tamoxifen india buy tamoxifen citrate canada order plavix 75 mg online can you buy plavix how to use kamagra tablets kamagra oral jelly usa how to get baby to take augmentin cheapest drug augmentin buy viagra plus lowest price generic viagra online reviews cheap acticin us order non prescription acticin decadron overnight order decadron 0.5 mg buy amitriptyline online uk pharmacy amitriptyline order online diovan medication coupons generic name for diovan hct zyvox india zyvox sales 2012 adalat without prescriptions cheap adalat 30 mg angina canada order estrace prescription estrace buy lisinopril generic brand lisinopril in usa canada order evista evista prescription information allegra d generic alternative canadian allegra suprax dosage for uti suprax order online revatio generic form buy revatio with generic version of prilosec otc prilosec prescription coupon bystolic pharmacy bystolic medication coupons order abilify 3mg online Purchase abilify 2mg licensed kamagra suppliers reviews buy cheap kamagra india alli diet pills discount voucher codes pharmacy alli dosage weight loss paxil canada lawsuit paxil from puerto rico robaxin generic available robaxin no prescription how to get propranolol buy propranolol 10 mg amantadine shortage legal to buy amantadine arimidex online buy arimidex online pharmacy how long does it take for lipitor to get out of your system lipitor online prescription tadacip mexico order tadacip 20mg online prescription pyridium dosage generic for pyridium where can i buy orlistat online orlistat over the counter williams pariet generic canada pariet pharmacy furosemide 40 mg buy online furosemide medication 40mg clomid pills pregnancy clomid overnight atarax tablets dosage atarax medication anxiety can you buy viagra online legally is generic viagra from india safe order clonidine 0.1 mg purchase clonidine cheap buy antivert us diclofenac australia buy diclofenac generic how to get a free sample of cialis generic cialis ukraine generic viagra super active reviews viagra professional prescriptions allegra without a transcript next day generic of allegra 180 buy allegra with discount pharmacy buy allegra online no prescription buy tinidazole tablets where to buy tinidazole online buy levitra super active with canada order levitra plus buy cheap orlistat tablets orlistat 120 mg cheap buy antibiotics tetracycline online buy tetracycline online safe cheap zetia tablets prescription zetia bentyl for sale canada order bentyl premarin dosage menopause delivery buy premarin online topic side effects of cipro medication uses for cipro medication hydrochlorothiazide prescription costs avalide medication hydrochlorothiazide floxin generic floxin mexico antibiotic bronchitis order zyprexa india cheap zyprexa manic olanzapine buy albendazole generic script purchase without generic albendazole buy prednisone online prednisone dosage for rheumatoid arthritis cephalexin commonly used generic cephalexin capsules hyzaar no prescription cheap cod hyzaar generic side effects alli medication reviews where to buy alli pills lexapro medicine used is lexapro generic celexa buy aciphex online usaa buy aciphex 1 rabeprazole 20mg generic minocin minocycline order minocycline no prescription where to zofran zofran overnight delivery how much does viagra cost in canada indian jelly order viagra online without hydrochlorothiazide overnight what is hydrochlorothiazide medication substitute for actos medication actos no prescription nexium 80 mg nexium pills side effects albendazole dosage for humans cheap albendazole overnight delivery buy diclofenac paypal diclofenac and misoprostol combination vermox generic name vermox dosage finpecia discount finasteride propecia buy propecia no prescription usa where can i buy accutane isotretinoin generic buy accutane uk online without proventil without rx proventil uk boots bupropion medication error purchase bupropion xl order atarax 10mg atarax by mail liposafe generic liposafe uk boots furosemide no prescription uk where to buy furosemide tenormin drugstore legal to buy tenormin bystolic online coupon bystolic pharmacy price albendazole through treatment medication generic name of albendazole prescription amaryl generic cheap prescription amaryl generic drugstore is it legal to buy viagra online in australia viagra super active discounted erythromycin by mail erythromycin overnight delivery can you buy alesse alesse no prescription pharmacy seroquel overnight fedex generic seroquel release date female viagra reviews cheap viagra pills online pharmacies canadian buy allegra over the counter canada order allegra nexium discount pharmacy nexium pharmacy online arimidex dosage order no prescription buy arimidex online is elimite over the counter ordering elimite online hydrochlorothiazide generic drug order hydrochlorothiazide 50mg zanaflex generic name where zanaflex cheapest drug alesse cheap canadian alesse cheapest drug diovan order pharmacy cheap diovan non prescription viagra australia generic viagra from india review delivery abilify online prescription abilify medication dosage buy viagra soft tab cheapest drug viagra soft canada order proventil proventil drugs com finasteride flomax combination flomax relief training bactrim discounted bactrim reviews side effects levitra professional medication levitra dosage 30 mg augmentin to buy online augmentin duo syrup dosage for children alesse medication ethinyl estradiol dosage buy cheap online pharmacy alesse canada can you buy cafergot buy cafergot online pharmacy erection packs 1 drugs cialis online pharmacy buy cialis online canada what is risperdal medication risperdal prescriptions hydrochlorothiazide generic medication hydrochlorothiazide no prescription needed cheap orlistat 60mg capsules orlistat buy online uk
Home Articles
Bratty Behavior: Two Major Players Clash in a Courtroom over Bratz Dolls’ Beginnings.

For those of us who collect dolls, they are more often than not sources of joy, pride, and wish fulfillment. In some cases, they cause extreme exasperation (when you miss out on a limited edition, for example) or financial consternation (did I really just spend $300barbieaslegallyblondeSMALL on a BJD . . . again?). When people play with their dolls, I imagine it’s a sense of revisiting happier days of yore—really coming home again emotionally and spiritually. So with all of these good vibrations and happy feelings floating around, why can’t Mattel and MGA Entertainment get along? Is it too much to expect them and their company lawyers to play nice?

On January 18, another round in the corporate slugfest has begun. A Santa Ana, California, courtroom was packed as the legal eagles began to wrangle once more over who really owns the rights to the Bratz Dolls, and all of their plastic paraphernalia, tie-in merchandise, franchise offshoots, and products (both past and present).

It’s hard to reconcile the notion of a courtroom ringing with slurs of shlockiness, charges of industrial spying, and heated exchanges about “lack of veracity and verisimilitude”—fancy ways of saying lies and truth—with the image of these brazen, bodacious Bratz dolls staring haughtily and imperiously from a toy store’s shelf. It seems that if these dolls ever got dragged into a court, it wouldn’t be on charges of corporate espionage, let me tell you!

Bratz have been the punch line about being inappropriate and risqué for about a decade now. Recently, a respected ABC newsman, Jake Tapper, blogged how he was scandalized to find his elementary-school daughter had a pair of these plump-lipped femme fatales in her bedroom. It made me chuckle that this war correspondent/White House analyst was blindsided by the tempest in his very own toy box! And to think, these plastic personalities are now being paraded into court, where their origins, their initial sketches, and their very conception are being verified and validated. (For doll historians, the feud over how the Bratz doll began—whose head did it figuratively spring from—is especially entertaining because of Barbie creator Ruth Handler’s admission of being “inspired” by a German Bild Lilli dollBildLilliBarbieSMALL while on vacation in Switzerland. People scolded Handler for copying the Teutonic tootsie too closely and so obviously.)

The CEO of Mattel, Robert Eckert, and his MGA counterpart, Isaac Larian, are both on hand as the fate of these vixens is decided. The court is going to render a decision that amounts to a multimillion-dollar change in fortune. Some reports have gone on to say this is a billion-dollar Bratz decision, but I don’t know if that’s just because of the alliteration or if the high-stakes nature is really that high stakes!

As the sides snipe at one another, the jury has to figure out if Bratz creator Carter Bryant, a former Mattel employee, was on the toy giant’s clock when he imagined these sultry substitutes. The Mattel lawyers are saying that the idea belongs to them, and Bryant was persuaded to share trade secrets with MGA when he deserted the Barbie-and-Ken corporation. MGA is likening themselves to David in an unfair battle against a mega-industry Goliath.

Susan Estrich, well-known talking head on FOX News, and one of Mattel’s corporate lawyers, shot back: “David made his own slingshot. He didn’t steal it!”

No matter how the jury decides, things don’t look good for the Bratz gals. If Mattel wins, will they allow these Angelina Jolie look-alikes to continue to see the light of day, or will they be rubbed out, confined to the trash heap of forgotten, onetime popular brands? Are they going to be sent to “swim” with the Fisher-Price outcasts—a fate reserved for toys that are no longer desired or desirable? Will they be whimsically whacked?

Or if MGA wins the proceedings, how sullied is their reputation? Even if the accusations against them are proven to be false, can the company pull itself together and rise above the charges of intellectual thievery, bribery, and industrial double-speak?

It’s been alleged that many retailers are shying away from the Bratz dolls these days—I never thought I’d type “shy” and “Bratz” in the same sentence. But supposedly, many companies don’t want to traffic with these dolls that are causing so many headaches and heartburn for Mattel.

With tens and tens of millions of dollars already spent, and more bills piling up over the next four months (that’s the estimate of this trial length), how much of a Bratz market share will be left for either company to capitalize upon?

All of this holds a particular interest for me because my daughter, Jane, who is six years old, just got the figure-skating/Olympic Ice Princess Bratz for Christmas.BratzonIceIceRinkPlaysetSMALL Jane is a real rough-and-tumble little girl who says she wants to grow up to be a “circus balancer, bug killer, spy, FBI agent, scientist, and minivan designer.” With so many careers before her, she uses her toys to enact her future occupations. The Bratz doll really captured her imagination because it spins and twirls, plus it came with a life-size gold medal. Jane played with this doll for hours—an accomplishment for her limited attention span—and she had the doll pretending to be a “circus balancer” because of her flexible, poseable limbs.

Now, with the court case in the news once more, and the accusations getting very specific and boiling over into charges of corporate espionage on both parties’ ends, Jane can add “spy” to her Bratz doll’s résumé. She doesn’t even need to imagine that; it’s being spelled out in black-and-white in court dockets even as she makes believe.

Where do you stand on this Barbie vs. Bratz battle? If you were put on the witness stand, on whose side would you testify? Or is there a way to bring the swift wisdom of Solomon to this solid case of he said/she said/they both said? Inquiring minds want to know!

 

PHOTO CAPTIONS

Barbie is one of Mattel’s most famous and recognizable properties. In her “Legally Blonde” vestments, she shows off what a formidable and popular opponent she can be. Will she be the victor in her toe-to-toe matchup against the Bratz lineup? [Top]

 

One of the strongly contested points of the Barbie vs. Bratz briefs is the origin of the Bratz doll. Who conceived it? When was it created? Did it belong to Mattel by virtue of their employment of Bratz designer Carter Bryant? These same allegations swirled around the birth of Barbie back in 1959, when industry watchers said she bore too strong a resemblance to the German doll Bild Lilli, a gag gift for men of the “Mad Men” era. [Middle]

 

The Bratz collectors will be spinning around in circles over the next few months, wondering if their preferred playthings will continue to exist in the near future. Currently, the fate of MGA and the Bratz franchise is skating on thin ice. [Bottom]

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (3)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
...
This isn't really about Mattel wanting ownership of the Bratz line. This is Mattel trying to take out their competition. Then they will be back on top again and have no serious competition to worry about. Not to long again they were losing out to Bratz. Now they have a chance to take them down. I hope MGA wins. Mattel needs some competition. I like both dolls, but fair is fair. I don't even thing Mattel should be paid off. The dolls look nothing like Barbie, and designing the Bratz dolls was a side job. I could understand if Bratz looked like Barbie, but since they don't, they should just leave it. Mattel is greedy and trying to cheat by taking out their competition.
Chelle , January 26, 2011 | url
...
I think they should split the profits so far, and Mattel should let MGA keep on making the dolls. Maybe they can take some money from future earnings. No need to destroy a whole company out of jealousy or anger? Mattel has so many big sellers already: Barbie, American Girls, Monster High. Let some other companies produce dolls, and accept some sort of payback as an early investor. why cant this be decided by a mediator? why is this in court?
Teena , January 22, 2011
...
just another pointless lawsuit clogging up our justice system. who doesn't sit in their current job and think about ways to better their situation, and plot it out? These girls should settle out of court!
Billie , January 22, 2011

Write comment

smaller | bigger

busy
 

Latest Articles from News & Notes

Jones Publishing Lifetime Achievement Award Winners

The Jones Publishing Lifetime Achievement Award is bestowed upon one recipient per year. This award was created in 2002 in conjunction with the 100th anniversary of the introduction of the teddy bear, with the first recipient being Steiff, a German-based plush toy company known for its high quality and prices.

The Lifetime Achievement recipient must be or have been involved in some aspect of the doll and/or teddy bear field for a minimum of 25 years. The recipient may be an individual, partnership, corporation, company, author, artist, marketer, historian or any other industry professional. Lifetime Achievement Award nominations may be made by previous recipients or members of the LAA committee.

To qualify as a nominee, entrants must meet the following criteria:

  • Been active in the doll or bear field a minimum of 25 years.
  • Maintained or increased the quality of reputation and product or service provided since inception.
  • Served the industry with integrity, honesty, reliability
  • Received a majority of the votes from previous recipients.

The Lifetime Achievement Award has been presented to the following individuals and companies since its inception:

2002 Steiff
2003 Hildegard Gunzel
2004 Alexander Doll Company
2005 R. John Wright
2006 Wendy Lawton
2007 Virginia Turner
2008 Toy Shoppe
2010 Helen Kish
2012 Maggie Iacono
2013 Heidi Plusczok
2014 Jack Johnston
2015 Kaye Wiggs
2016 Robert Tonner

 

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (0)

Write comment

smaller | bigger

One World Doll Project, Tonner Doll Company merge to become Tonner One World

One World Holdings, Inc. and Tonner Doll Company, Inc., announced Dec. 3, 2015, that their Boards of Directors have approved a definitive agreement for One World Holdings' subsidiary, The One World Doll Project, to merge with Tonner Doll. The agreement was entered into Dec. 2. Following the closing of the merger, the combined business will change its name to Tonner One World.

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (1)

...
Very informative article. I am happy for Tonner Doll and hope that their new venture enables them to continue creating beautiful dolls.
Terri Gold , December 05, 2015 | url

Write comment

smaller | bigger

Read more...
2015 DOLLS Awards Industry's Choice winners announced

The 2015 DOLLS Awards of Excellence Industry’s Choice winners (DAEs, also called the Diamond Awards) were announced at the International Doll & Teddy Bear Show in Asheville, N.C., June 6. The Industry's Choice winners will go on to become the nominee's in the Public's Choice voting, set to begin in late June.

Without further ado, here are the winners of this year's Industry's Choice Diamond Awards!

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (0)

Write comment

smaller | bigger

Read more...
BLACKALL ASSOCIATES INC. 
ANNOUNCING Winner of the Summer Heat Photo Contest

August 8, 2014 - Blackall Associates Inc. is proud to announce the winner of its Summer Heat Photo Contest. The contest drew entries from around the world. Masterpiece Doll collectors sent in a special photo showing how their Masterpiece Dolls were enjoying the summer heat. 

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (2)

...
i have very old magazines need to sell them before something happens to them
margie , December 20, 2014
...
i really like all the barbie balack dress, can i ask question can i buy this, because its all out in the market now here in the philippines, can you help me please im a big fan of thiss dolls
mark christian paul l. carigma , December 16, 2014 | url

Write comment

smaller | bigger

Read more...
The Chicago Toy Show

You haven’t seen a toy show until you’ve seen this one. Six buildings! Over six hundred exhibitors! Exclusively toys and dolls and children’s playthings on display everywhere! This is the show everyone always says they intend to visit, and now is the time to do just that. Collectors say the Chicago Toy Show really is the largest in the entire world. They are correct. Collectors say they find toys at this show that are never seen anywhere else. Correct again.

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (0)

Write comment

smaller | bigger

Read more...